An impairment rating is a medical determination. A PPD rating is a legal one. Physicians produce the first. States, courts, and insurers produce the second. The two are often referred to interchangeably, but they are not the same, and understanding the difference is essential to performing your role correctly and keeping your reports out of litigation.
What Is an Impairment Rating?
An impairment rating is a physician's medical assessment of the permanent functional loss a patient has sustained from an injury or illness. It is expressed as a Whole Person Impairment (WPI) percentage, calculated using the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment. The physician's job is to measure, document, and report the WPI. Nothing more.
The impairment rating is objective and standardized. The same diagnosis, evaluated by trained physicians using the same edition of the AMA Guides, should produce the same result regardless of which attorney hired the physician or which side of the claim they are evaluating.
What Is a PPD Rating?
Permanent Partial Disability (PPD) is a legal and administrative classification that determines compensation for a worker who has sustained a permanent work-related injury. PPD is calculated by applying the WPI to each jurisdiction's specific formulas, schedules, and statutory multipliers. The same WPI will produce different PPD amounts in different states.
In Nevada, for example, PPD is calculated under the Nevada Industrial Insurance Act using statutory formulas that incorporate the WPI, the claimant's pre-injury wages, and applicable adjustments. In California, the WPI is converted using the Permanent Disability Rating Schedule, which incorporates age and occupation modifiers. These are legal calculations, not medical ones.
Where the Physician's Role Ends
The physician's role in a PPD claim ends when the impairment rating report is submitted. The physician calculates and documents the WPI. Everything that follows (the PPD determination, benefit calculation, and any legal proceedings arising from disputes about the rating) is outside the physician's scope.
A rating report that strays into the PPD determination is a report that has exceeded its author's role. Statements like "the patient is entitled to X weeks of benefits" or "this injury results in a 30% permanent disability" are legal conclusions that belong to the state agency or court. Including them invites challenge.
What About Permanent Total Disability?
PPD (Permanent Partial Disability) is distinct from PTD (Permanent Total Disability). PPD means the patient retains some work capacity. PTD means the patient cannot engage in any gainful employment. Both are legal classifications derived in part from the WPI, but they involve additional vocational, economic, and legal analysis that goes well beyond the physician's impairment rating.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does PPD vary by state even if the WPI is the same?
Yes. A 20% WPI in California will produce a different PPD award than the same rating in Nevada, Texas, or Florida. Each state applies its own schedule, multipliers, and adjustments.
Can a treating physician perform an impairment rating?
Either a treating or IME physician can rate, depending on the state. Several states (including Nevada) require that any physician performing PPD ratings hold specific certification before they are eligible to perform rated evaluations.
What is the difference between PPD and PTD?
PPD (Permanent Partial Disability) means the patient retains some work capacity. PTD (Permanent Total Disability) means the patient cannot engage in any gainful employment. Both are legal classifications derived in part from the WPI.
Produce impairment ratings that hold up. Get CIRS™ certified through AAEME, with CME/CEU credit for MDs, DOs, and DCs.
Learn More →